Grand Island FL Homes for Sale | Community Guide & Expert Insights
Explore Grand Island FL homes for sale, a serene Lake County escape near Eustis and Lake Eustis. Affordable properties from $300K, ideal for families and retirees. Garrison Realty Group offers hyper-local guidance and 3D tours.
Grand Island FL homes for sale offer peaceful living in Lake County’s unincorporated ZIP 32735, minutes from Eustis. Median prices ~$345K (up 7% YoY) include family homes, 55+ retreats, and waterfront gems on Lake Eustis. Grand Island Elementary serves young families, and Lake Yale offers boating. Check Lake County Property Appraiser for tax data or Discover Lake County Florida for local events. Homes for sale in Grand Island FL boast low HOA and boat access at Marsh Park. Garrison Realty Group delivers personalized searches—contact us today.
Living in Grand Island, FL
Garrison Realty Group knows homes for sale in Grand Island FL, from waterfront retreats to family homes, and offers personalized tours and market insights. Broker/Owner Jennifer Garrison brings over 20 years of Central Florida experience to every closing. Explore Grand Island FL homes for sale with us—call (352) 805-5550 or email Jen@GarrisonRealty.Group.
Garrison Realty Group, LLC brings passion and expertise to Grand Island FL homes for sale, redefining the real estate experience in Central Florida. Grand Island rewards buyers who know its market: waterfront homes on Lake Eustis and Lake Yale, boat access at Marsh Park, 55+ neighborhoods, and family homes near Grand Island Elementary, all served with hands-on, one-on-one service big box brokerages can’t match. Relentless problem-solving and compassionate guidance mean clients feel supported every step of the way—whether buying their dream home, selling a cherished property, or navigating complex deals in Grand Island, FL. From professional photos and 3D tours to tailored strategies, we use Garrison’s innovative tools to craft personalized solutions that turn clients into lifelong friends, with strategic market insight and unmatched personal attention at every step.
Contact Jennifer Garrison
[showcaseidx_contact]Current Grand Island FL Homes for Sale
Browse top homes for sale in Grand Island FL—prices from $300K. We have the inside scoop on waterfront gems and new builds.
Homes for sale in Grand Island
View propertiesGrand Island, Florida Real Estate
Looking for Grand Island FL homes for sale?
Grand Island FL homes for sale are your gateway to Central Florida’s hidden gem, and Garrison Realty Group, led by Broker/Owner Jennifer Garrison, is here to guide you. Grand Island Florida real estate ranges from affordable homes in Grand Island Florida to Grand Island FL homes with pool and 55+ communities. Our boutique approach redefines the real estate experience, combining relentless problem-solving with hands-on service. Whether you’re searching for family homes in Grand Island FL, exploring Grand Island Florida neighborhoods, or need to sell a home in Grand Island FL, local market trends and amenities shape every decision. Garrison’s innovative marketing, like 3D tours, showcases Grand Island FL properties for sale like no other. Curious about Grand Island Florida home values? Check the Lake County Property Appraiser or contact Garrison Realty Group for market insights and tailored strategies to meet your goals. Reach Jennifer Garrison at (352) 805-5550 or Jen@GarrisonRealty.Group to buy or sell in Grand Island, FL, and experience real estate with a neighbor’s heart and a bulldog’s tenacity. Explore Central Florida market trends today.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the median cost of homes for sale in Grand Island FL?
The median listing price for homes for sale in Grand Island FL is ~$368,900 (October 2025), up 10.3% YoY. Average home values are $322,684, down 2.3%. Contact Jennifer Garrison for current listings and market updates.
What schools serve Grand Island FL?
Grand Island FL is in Lake County Schools, with Umatilla Elementary (PK-5), Eustis High (9-12), and Tavares High (9-12). Umatilla Elementary excels for young families—check the district site for zoning.
What is the electric company for Grand Island FL?g Text Here
SECO Energy serves Grand Island FL and rural Lake County with reliable power, outage alerts, and billing support. Visit their website to set up service or get help.
How is fishing in Grand Island FL?
Fishing in Grand Island FL is a blast on Lake Eustis (Harris Chain), with largemouth bass galore. Canals and shell beds are hot year-round—Texas-rigged worms work magic along 15+ miles of shoreline.
Where are the best fishing spots near Grand Island FL?
Top fishing spots include Lake Eustis (shell beds for bass), Lake Harris (Leesburg for trophies), and Lake George (Astor). St. Johns River and Lake Minneola are close—launch from Marsh Park ramps.
Are there sandbars for boat gatherings near Grand Island FL?
Lake Dora’s sandbar (~10 min from Grand Island) is a boaters’ party spot for music and swimming. July’s Sand Bar Boat-In is huge—check local FB groups for Lake Eustis pop-ups.
Are there waterfront homes for sale in Grand Island FL?
Yes, waterfront homes for sale in Grand Island FL on Lake Eustis and Lake Yale range from $400K-$600K, with Marsh Park boat access. Jennifer Garrison has the latest listings.
Where can I take my boat for dinner near Grand Island FL?
Boat to Lake Eustis Waterfront Grille (350 Lakeshore Dr, Eustis) for steaks, Hurricane Dockside (Lake Eustis-Harris) for festive eats, or Fish Camp on Lake Eustis for farm-to-table.
What is the average HOA fee in Grand Island FL?
HOA fees in Grand Island FL, like in Lakeshore Club, range $150-$350 monthly for maintenance, pools, and security. Fees vary by neighborhood—ask Jennifer for details.
What are the real estate market trends in Grand Island FL?
Grand Island FL real estate is hot, with median prices at $368,900 (up 10.3% YoY) and average values at $322,684 (down 2.3%). Low inventory favors sellers—Jennifer Garrison guides buyers fast.
EXCELLENT
★★★★★
Based on 19 reviews
Posted on Google
D Rollins
★★★★★
Jennifer was everything we could have asked for in a realtor when buying our first home! Her experience in the industry made the process smooth every step of the way even when we came across obstacles. She explained everything to us and made us feel comfortable and informed to make the best decision. I would recommend Jen to anyone looking for a home. She also makes a great baby sitter ;)
Posted on Google
Becky Colligan
★★★★★
What an amazing experience! Jennifer was the best from day 1. She was there for me for the highs and lows of selling my house. There are a lot of moving parts during the sell and she made sure we transitioned into our new home with such ease. I would personally 1000% recommend Jennifer Garrison:)
Posted on Google
Rafael Sainz
★★★★★
Very dedicated to her clients!
Posted on Google
Alexander Connell
★★★★★
Jennifer was an absolute pleasure to work with. She is truly there for you, and cares about her clients. Jennifer has a wealth of knowledge about the industry and takes the time to understand her clients. Jennifer did an amazing job making sure everything ran smoothly throughout the lending process. I would highly recommend Jennifer to any friends or family.
Posted on Google
Vincent Peltzer
★★★★★
After moving to Mount Dora my wife and I decided we wanted to live closer to downtown in order to be able to walk rather than drive. Since we no longer wanted to buy but rent or lease a home or apartment so I contacted Jennifer and so glad we did.
Jennifer responded soon after my inquiry. We had come across a couple of possibilities but I knew from experience a good property management/broker was the way to go. Sure enough right away she sent us a couple of listings we had not seen
Jennifer has been suck a delight to work with and has gone out of her way to help us. Right now we're submitting an application and really hope we get the place. If we don't we'll go right back to Jennifer with all the confidence we'll find what we want.
Posted on Google
Melissa Meghdadi
★★★★★
I had a rough start with a previous broker qith the sale of my home and was feeling discouraged, but then I found Jen—and she completely turned things around. She went above and beyond in ways that I didn’t even expect from a broker. From the start, Jen was professional, supportive, and incredibly communicative, always keeping me in the loop after showings. Unlike others, she never pressured me to make unnecessary changes to my home. Instead, she focused on getting it sold—and she did just that.
What really stood out is how much Jen truly cares about her clients. Whether you’re selling or buying a modest home or a high-end property, she treats everyone with the same dedication, respect, and attention to detail. Jen made the entire process feel manageable and smooth. I can't recommend her highly enough!
Posted on Google
Brandon Erwin
★★★★★
Had the best experience with Jennifer. She and her husband were not only professional, but they have the personal touch that kept a smile on my face the entire time we spent with them. Please make the time to call her for advice on your Realty needs. Walked in customers, left as friends.
Posted on Google
Grace Abele
★★★★★
I had the absolute pleasure of working with Jen during my home-buying journey, and I cannot recommend her highly enough! From start to finish, she was incredibly knowledgeable, professional, and attentive to every detail.
As a first time homebuyer, Jen took the time to provide expert guidance and honest advice throughout the entire process. Her communication was always clear and prompt, making sure I felt informed and confident every step of the way.
Posted on Google
Kathryn Wilhelm Drucker
★★★★★
Jen is extremely knowledgeable and goes above and beyond for her clients.
Posted on Google
Christine Schwartz
★★★★★
Jen is the best! When we were having issues with our finance company, she continued to help us in anyway she could. She is excellent as a Realtor and an awesome person!